McCollum v. Board of Education
McCollum v. Board of Education, 333 U.S. 203 (1948), was a landmark case ruled upon by the United States Supreme Court in 1948, and related to the power of a state to use its tax-supported public school system in aid of religious instruction. The case was an early test of the separation of church and state with respect to education.
The case tested the principle of "released time", where public schools set aside class time for religious instruction. The Court's ruling struck down the Champaign, Illinois program as unconstitutional, using as a basis for its judgment the involvement of the public school system in the administration, organization and support of the religious instruction classes. The Court's ruling noted that some 2,000 communities nationwide offered similar "released time" programs affecting 1.5 million students.
The case was brought by Vashti McCollum, the mother of a student enrolled in the Champaign public school district.
In 1940, a number of interested members of various Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish faiths formed an association named the Champaign Council on Religious Education. This association sought and obtained permission from the Champaign Board of Education to offer voluntary religious education classes for public school students from grades four to nine. These weekly 30- and 45-minute classes were led by clergy and lay members of the association in public school classrooms during school hours.
McCollum — an avowed atheist — objected to the religious classes, and stated that her son James was ostracized for not attending the religious classes. After complaints to school officials to stop offering these classes went unheeded, McCollum sued the school board in July 1945, stating that the religious instruction in the public schools violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment — the principle of separation of church and state in the United States. McCollum also complained that the school district's religious education classes violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The principal elements of the McCollum complaint were that
 In actual practice certain Protestant groups exercised an advantage over other Protestant denominations.
Though defined by the school district as "voluntary", this designation was in name only because of pressure exerted by school officials on students to coerce or force their participation.
The power exercised by the Champaign Council on Religious Education in its selection of instructors, and the school superintendent's oversight of these instructors served to determine which religious faiths participate in the instructional program, and constituted a prior censorship of religion.
In her suit, McCollum asked that the Board of Education be ordered to "adopt and enforce rules and regulations prohibiting all instruction in and teaching of all religious education in all public schools in Champaign District Number 71, and in all public school houses and buildings in said district when occupied by public schools."
The Circuit Court of Champaign County ruled in favor of the school district in January 1946, and upon appeal the Illinois Supreme Court affirmed the lower court's ruling.
McCollum appealed the case to the U. S. Supreme Court, which agreed to hear the case, taking oral arguments in December 1947. On March 8 1948, the Court ruled 8-1 in favor of McCollum, ruling that the classes were unconstitutional.
In the majority opinion, written by Justice Hugo Black, the Court held that
The lone dissenting justice, Stanley Forman Reed, objected to the breadth of the majority's interpretation of the Establishment Clause and stated that an incidental support of religion should have been permissible with a more narrow reading of the First Amendment.
The Supreme Court's ruling remanded the case to the Illinois high court for relief consistent with the federal ruling.
The high court revisited the issue of religious instruction in Zorach v. Clauson in 1952. The 6 to 3 ruling in the later case held that a New York program allowing religious education during the school day was permissible, because it did not use public school facilities or public funds.
See also
Separation of church and state
Released time
Zorach v. Clauson
List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 333
External links
TIME article on McCollum v. Board of Education case in circuit court, dated September 24, 1945
TIME article on Illinois Supreme Court's ruling against McCollum, dated February 10, 1947
TIME article on oral arguments before U.S. Supreme Court, dated December 22, 1947
TIME article on U.S. Supreme Court ruling in favor of McCollum, dated March 22, 1948
TIME article on theologists' views of ruling in McCollum case, dated July 19, 1948
TIME article on Catholic bishops' denunciation of Supreme Court ruling, dated November 29, 1948
|
|
|
|
This section is sponsored by:
Mccollum v Board Of Education Listings
Your Source for Mccollum v Board Of Education. Find and Compare Mccollum v Board Of Education Listings Here
www.AreaConnect.com
Mccollum v Board Of Education Listings
Your Source for Mccollum v Board Of Education. Find and Compare Mccollum v Board Of Education Listings Here.
www.Findlinks.com
RobotBooks: Robot Kits, Books, Toys!
Reviews of robotics books, plus robot kits, movies, magazines, and toy robots. Click here for an introduction to an interesting and fun new hobby!
www.robotbooks.com
Lowest Priced Computers
Get the lowest prices on laptops, desktops and computer accessories
www.Geeks.com
HP Laptops & Notebooks
Find great deals on HP laptops & notebooks along with accessories for your computer.
www.shopping.hp.com
Complete Laptop &Accessories
Need laptop &accessories in new tech? Find here at affordable Price.
Computer-Laptop.net
Get a Mac Computer
Find the Mac computer that fits your needs from the Macbook to the iMac
store.apple.com
Laptop & Desktop Computers
Find great deals & low prices brand name laptops and desktop computers.
www.buy.com
|
